Uploads from Shamounian Explains

Currently Playing: Sam Shamoun Refutes Muslim Shabir Ally On Jesus Prophecies Being “MADE UP”

Sam Shamoun refutes and breaks down a claim from a Muslim debator named shabir ally saying that the Gospel writers deliberately shaped Jesus's story to artificially match Old Testament prophecies, and dismantles it by pointing out this ignores a much more basic historical question: what would have motivated Jews and Gentiles to continue proclaiming a Messiah who had just been publicly killed and buried, since history shows failed messianic movements typically collapsed the moment their leader died, as seen with the second century revolutionary Bar Kokhba, who was hailed as the star prophesied in Numbers 24:17 before being killed and mockingly renamed Bar Koziba, "son of the lie." Sam argues it makes far more sense that the disciples, faced with the shock of a genuinely crucified and risen Messiah, were driven back into the Old Testament to discover in hindsight how the suffering servant prophecies of Isaiah actually pointed to this unexpected pattern all along, rather than fabricating events to retroactively force a match. He then exposes what he calls a direct contradiction in the critic's argument, showing that the same person claims the Gospel writers invented details to fulfill Isaiah 53's prophecy of a silent suffering servant, while also admitting the Gospels have Jesus speaking up in his own defense, which would actually undermine that supposed fulfillment rather than support it. Sam clarifies that Isaiah 53's silence refers specifically to the servant not defending himself against the charge worthy of death, not literal muteness, and walks through how the Gospel trial narratives show Jesus never contesting the blasphemy verdict or pleading with Pilate to spare his life, even while addressing other questions, which he argues exposes the critic's inconsistency rather than the Gospels' own. Timestamps📌 0:00 Muslim Shabir Ally claims the Gospels were shaped to fit Old Testament prophecy 5:00 Why failed messiahs are quickly abandoned 16:00 Jesus's silence before his accusers Like 👍 Share to Other Christian Brother & Sisters ❤️ ✅Subscribe Subscribe to ​⁠​⁠Shamounian Sam Shamouns Articles to Help with Christian / Islam objections https://answeringislam.blog/690ca956ea00a60f4925c2c7-2/ https://answering-islam.org Support the Channel by helping put out videos more consistently and with more topics for all christians ❤️🙏 https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC6uIGfgTH4x4360B0RDl4hg/join Tiktok where i repost other clips: https://www.tiktok.com/@islam_to_jesuschrist?_t=ZP-8zjalwdkjnC&_r=1 Tiktok BackUp: https://www.tiktok.com/@islam_to_jesuschrist2?_r=1&_t=ZP-97GQXc80oow Instagram where i also post clips: https://www.instagram.com/shamounianexplains?igsh=enJ4YTB5ejVuc3B5&utm_source=qr #samshamoun #christian #muslim #bible